Skip to content
Meets Obsession homeMeet your next obsession.
FashionNew in MO
AN OPINION

Wear Two Different Earrings. Matching Is for Socks.

ask Peggy.

The pair was always a suggestion. A collector proved it in 1942, punk proved it again in 1977, and your jewelry box is proving it right now.

A woman with slicked-back dark hair and red lipstick against a red backdrop, wearing one earring shaped like a small wire mobile with yellow, blue and black shapes and one earring that is a tiny framed abstract painting

On the night of Oct. 20, 1942, Peggy Guggenheim opened her gallery in New York wearing two earrings that had never met. One was a tiny mobile by Alexander Calder. The other was a miniature painting by Yves Tanguy. Her gallery showed abstract art and Surrealist art, the two camps couldn't stand each other, and she wanted everyone in the room to know she wasn't picking a side.

It's the best excuse anyone's ever had for a mismatched pair. You don't need one that good.

Somewhere along the way, we all agreed that earrings come in twos, like shoes. But shoes have a job. Earrings are decoration, and decoration has no reason to repeat itself. Your face isn't symmetrical. Your hair doesn't part in the middle. The matched pair is a jeweler's convenience that got mistaken for a law.

Punk knew.

In 1977, the earring of choice on the King's Road was a single safety pin, and nobody asked where the other one was. Through the 1980s, one earring was the whole statement: a cross, a feather, a dagger, hanging on its own like a word said once. It's on every album cover you love from the decade. It worked because one earring looks like a decision and a pair looks like a purchase.

Here's the practical case, and it's a strong one. You've lost an earring. Everyone has. The survivor is sitting in a dish right now with four other survivors, and together they're the most interesting jewelry you own. Each one was good enough that you bought it and loved it enough that you kept it after its partner left. That dish isn't a graveyard. It's a collection.

So wear them. A few ways in, if you'd like a map:

Illustration: four cards showing ways to wear mismatched earrings. One, a long drop with a stud. Two, a gold hoop with a gold bar. Three, one big star earring and a bare ear. Four, a small mobile with a tiny framed painting.
Pick two that have never met.

Long and short. One drop that reaches your jaw, one stud. This is the beginner's version and it never looks like a mistake, because the difference is too big to be an accident.

Same metal, different shape. A gold hoop and a gold bar. They agree on color and argue about everything else, which is how the best outfits work.

One and none. A single big earring and a bare ear, hair tucked behind the loud side. The 1980s were right about this.

The Guggenheim. Two earrings that represent two things you refuse to choose between. Hers were art movements. Yours can be whatever you're being asked to pick between this week.

The objection we hear is that it looks unfinished. Good. Finished is what you look like in a passport photo. We've said the same about the coat you're saving and the glitter you gave up at 12: the things that make getting dressed fun are usually the things someone told you were for children or for later.

Guggenheim's London years are getting a museum show this winter, and we've told the story of those two earrings at more length. She wore them to settle an argument between abstraction and Surrealism. Neither side won. The earrings did.

Go to the dish. Pick two that have never met.

See who notices first.

Keep it loud

More Fashion ▶
back to top ▲